Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Rainbow Road



A. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Sanchez, Alex.2005. RAINBOW ROAD. Simon & Schuster: New York. ISBN 9780689865657.

B. PLOT SUMMARY
The characters are Jason, a jock who as newly come out as gay, his partner Kyle, a scholarly boy who has known he is gay for sometime, and Kyle's best friend Nelson, a flamboyant irresponsible boy who has also been out for sometime. When Jason receives an invitation to speak at a GLBTQ oriented high school in California, Kyle and Neslon decide to drive across the country with him. This road trip brings them many experiences, none of which they expected. They stay with wildly costumed gays at a commune in Tennessee, and with a cross-dressing "heshe" in the deep south. They meet a stable gay couple at a truck stop and dance with bisexuals at a club. They also are chased and threatened by rednecks. When they arrive in Los Angeles, Jason makes up a speech on the spot that summarizes what he's learned from their road trip. And Kyle falls in love and decides to stay in L.A.

C. CRITICAL REVIEW
RAINBOW ROAD is the third book in the RAINBOW trilogy, including RAINBOW BOYS and RAINBOW HIGH. While in earlier books author Alex Sanchez focuses on issues surrounding coming out, RAINBOW ROAD focuses on what to do after coming out. The book asks what is gay culture? Each boy begins the road trip thinking that gay culture must be something like themselves- and they are each very different. They find Nelson's flamboyance in Tennessee and Kyle's stability in a middle-aged gay couple. Josh recognizes people like himself in a club in New Orleans. But their real lesson in tolerance comes from being on the road with one another. Kyle and Josh almost break up under the strain. By the time they get to L.A. they are all barely talking to one another. Along with the Josh, Kyle and Nelson, we learn that gay culture is not one thing. As author Marc Aronson says, "if we look closely at any culture we will see all kinds of conflicting and mixed values, all sorts of opinions and many different points of view."1

The chapters of RAINBOW ROAD alternate between the perspectives of each of the three main characters. This is subtly done. Perhaps a little too subtly, since the voices of the characters don't sound strikingly different from one another. Author Sanchez's writing isn't the highest of quality, and at times he manages to sound a bit like the lecturing older brother- warning about the combination of drinking and sex, for example. Perhaps this is because Sanchez was a counselor for youth and families before he started writing. The book sometimes suffers from identity confusion, struggling between being a story and a guidance manual. One wonders whether it is more important to Sanchez to simply write a
GLBTQ book so teens could have something to relate to or whether he has an important story to tell. This is not to say that it isn't important for GLBTQ teens to see a reflection of themselves on the shelves. As David Levithan says, "when we talk about the books in a library, we call them a collection. But to a young reader- especially a teen reader- its really more a representation. Teens read to find themselves within the pages, and they visit libraries to find themselves on the shelves”.2 Still, it should not be a question of either a GLBTQ guide or a compelling story. A book can be both. RAINBOW ROAD can also seem superficial in places, and so focused on details as to be a bit boring. But the effect of RAINBOW ROAD is cumulative. It is not until the last quarter of the book that all the more superficial details add up into an emotionally compelling story that resonates on a universal level while broadening our empathy and knowledge about gay culture. It was worth the trip.

D. REVIEW EXCERPTS:

From School Library Journal:
Grade 9 Up–The final installment of this trilogy is a true winner. Even though coming out publicly resulted in Virginia high school basketball star Jason Carrillo's losing his college athletic scholarship, it turned him into an important role model for gay and lesbian teens. And so, when a new GLBT high school in Los Angeles is searching for a keynote speaker for its opening ceremony, it is not surprising that Jason is given an all-expenses-paid invitation. His boyfriend, Kyle, definitely wants to be there, too. And Kyle's best friend–pink-haired, boy-hungry Nelson–has a car and thinks that this would be the perfect opportunity for a post-senior-year road trip. Virginia to L.A. by car: 3000 miles and plenty of time to gain an understanding of what being gay in America is all about. These boys are distinct personalities and genuine teens, searching for clarity and identity and acceptance, trying to make sense of themselves and a world that can be equally bright and dark. Sanchez writes with humor and compassion. Some mature romance scenes, occasional frank language, and an inclusion of transgender/transsexual/bisexual story lines translate into a tender book that will likely be appreciated and embraced by young adult readers.–Jeff Katz, Queens Borough Public Library, NY

From Booklist:
Gr. 9-12. The third and final novel about gay teen friends Jason, Kyle, and Nelson finds the boys on a road trip, driving across country from their D.C. homes to Los Angeles, where Jason has been invited to speak at the opening of an alternative high school. Along the way, the young men encounter a variety of people and situations that occasionally seem clearly designed to educate the reader--for example, a transgender boy who looks like Britney Spears; an enclave of Radical Faeries who live off the land in rural Tennessee; a devoted gay couple who have been partners for 20 years; and, of course, the usual homophobes. In short, there's plenty of expected stuff. About halfway through the cross-country journey, however, Kyle begins questioning his relationship with bisexual Jason, and the story becomes more involving as characterization finally takes the driver's seat. Flamboyant Nelson remains annoyingly predictable, alas, but the other two boys are sympathetic charmers, and fans of Sanchez's first two Rainbow novels will certainly want to read this one. Michael Cart

E. CONNECTIONS
BOOKS:
  • Rainbow High (by Alex Sanchez)
  • Rainbow Boys (by Alex Sanchez)
  • Geography Club (by Brent Hartinger)
  • Peter (by Kate Walker)
ACTIVITIES:
  • Group Activity: Have everyone in the group secretly choose a color in the rainbow. Then make a "law" that blue people are wrong, and everyone will ridicule anyone who reveals that they are the color blue. Have people mingle with one another, asking questions to try to find out about the color of everyone else. Suddenly announce a change in the law. Now red people are bad. Go through the different colors. Use this exercise to start a discussion about young gay, lesbian and questioning people. How does it feel to have to hide what you are?
______________
1
. Marc Aronson, "A Mess of Stores" in Stories Matter: The Complexity of Cultural Authenticity in Children's Literature, ed. Dana L. Fox & Kathy G. Short (Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers) 79.

2. Levithan, David. 2004. Supporting gay teen culture: An advocate speaks out for representation on libarary shelves. School Library Journal 50(10): 44.

Rules




A. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Lord, Cynthia.2006. RULES. Scholastic Press: New York. ISBN 9780439443821.

B. PLOT SUMMARY

RULES is written from the perspective of twelve-year old Catherine, older sister to autistic David. Her family has just moved into a new neighborhood, and Catherine is scared that David will scare away new friends. Although she does make one almost friend in the neighborhood, it is complicated by the social politics of school. She receives an offer of friendship from the most unexpected source- a teenage boy in a wheelchair who cannot speak. He genuinely appreciates her art that she carries around in a notebook, and soon she is making word cards to help him communicate all the teenage emotions that his parents don't want to hear. Under all of this is Catherine's on-going relationship with her brother, which is a mixture of embarrassment, frustration, and genuinely trying to help him cope by creating "rules" he can memorize to make his life easier.

C. CRITICAL REVIEW

Dr. Vardell
quotes Hutchins and Heim in identifying five criteria by which to evaluate children's books that depict characters with disabilities: accuracy; avoidance of stereotypes; literary quality; confrontation of the disability and not "using" disabled characters.1 RULES does very well when evaluated by these criteria. RULES is accurate, most likely because the author Cynthia Lord wrote the book to "explore some of my own questions about living with someone who sees the world so differently than I do, but also to show a full experience of a family life with a child with autism: the happy moments, the heartbreaking ones, the ones that make me laugh." RULES avoids stereotypes, rather than using a disabled person to evoke fear (horror films featuring a serial killer in a wheelchair) or sympathy (Beth, in Little Women, always so weak and pale). David is a mischievous, innocent, force of nature. He is full of his own unique Davidness. RULES is well written, with short sentences that stick to the facts and lots of dialogue. RULES confronts autism straight on, it is never delegated to a background role, quite simply because lives associated with autistic individuals often must revolve around those people. Having worked for two years with autistic people, this aspect of autism speaks clearly to me. Finally, RULES does not use the disabled character. Although it is certainly true that Catherine learns about herself, continually, through her relationship with David.
There have been many books over the last few years featuring characters on the autistic-Asperger's spectrum. Most of them are highly functional and solve crimes, or have special abilities like Dustin Hoffman in Rainman. It is good that RULES is more realistic. One wonders where the books are on all the other disabilities. Where are the detectives in wheelchairs and with MS? One hopes they are coming soon.

D. REVIEW EXCERPTS

Publishers Weekly:

The appealing, credible narrator at the heart of Lord's debut novel will draw in readers, as she struggles to find order and balance in her life. Her parents place 12-year-old Catherine in charge of her younger autistic brother more often than she would like. Taking solace in art, the girl fills the back of her sketchbook with rules she has established for David, "so if my someday-he'll-wake-up-a-regular-brother wish doesn't ever come true, at least he'll know how the world works, and I won't have to keep explaining things." Sorely missing her best friend, who is away for the summer, and realizing that the girl who has just moved in next door is not a kindred spirit, Catherine devises some of her own self-protective rules ("When you want to get out of answering something, distract the questioner with another question"). In the able hands of the author, mother of an autistic child, Catherine's emotions come across as entirely convincing, especially her alternating devotion to and resentment of David, and her guilt at her impatience with him. Through her artwork, the heroine gradually opens up to Jason, a wheelchair-bound peer who can communicate only by pointing to words on cards. As she creates new cards that expand Jason's ability to express his feelings, their growing friendship enables Catherine to do the same. A rewarding story that may well inspire readers to think about others' points of view. Ages 9-12. (Apr.) Copyright 2006 Reed Business Information.

Joan Kindig, Ph.D. - Children's Literature:

Growing up with an autistic younger brother is not easy and it seems far harder when the pre-teen years hit. Catherine feels as though David's needs far overshadow her own in the family but the embarrassment his behavior causes her is the worst of it. Nevertheless, Catherine understands what David's world is like and when she snaps at him, she is beset by guilt. It is this sensitivity that allows her to befriend a boy her age with severe communication problems who is wheelchair-bound. Gaining a stronger sense of herself and demanding what she needs as a member of the family allows her to move beyond embarrassment into acceptance. This is a story that depicts the impact of a needy child on an entire family very realistically. One of the treats in this book is that David echoes words rather than generating his own and he frequently speaks in lines he remembers from Arnold Lobel's Frog & Toad. 2006, Scholastic, Ages 9 to 12.



E. CONNECTIONS
BOOKS:
  • The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time (by Mark Haddon)
  • The London Eye Mystery (by Siobhan Dowd)
ACTIVITIES:
  • Nothing can replace interacting with Autistic people! Invite an autistic person to come and speak about his or her experience.


Does My Head Look Big In This?



A. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Adel-Faffah, Randa. 2007. DOES MY HEAD LOOK BIG IN THIS?. Scholastic Inc: New York. ISBN: 9780439922333.

B. PLOT SUMMARY
Amal Mohamed Nasrullah Abdel-Hakim, a high school student, decides to wear the headscarf "full time". It is the toughest decision she has made, for she knows she will face the ridicule of her schoolmates at her fancy preparatory school, as well as her neighbors and friends. The book follows her in the course of her headscarf wearing, and although she receives her share of criticism from neighbors and classmates, she also discovers some true friends, helps people learn about Muslim culture, and feels empowered to be her true self.


C. CRITICAL REVIEW
Amal is a Palestinian Muslim and a typical Australian teen. So what is her culture? As Curt Dudley-Manning points out:

culture is a process by which people make- and remake- meaning in their lives..
it may appear that immigrants are mainly in the business of preserving their
cultures but, in fact, people actively reinvent their cultures in order to make
sense of their lives in new geographical, social, and political surroundings. 1

Amal, then, has created her own unique culture, reinvented out of her Palestinian and Muslim heritage along with all the accouterments of the modern teenage girl: makeup; Cosmo magazine; texting and IMing; ice cream and pizza and, yes, boys. Her family's reinvention of culture is much different than her friend Leila's. While both families are Muslim and the females wear head scarves outside the home, Amal's parents are modern Muslims, while Lelia's mother mixes her traditional Turkish culture with Islam and insists that Leila accept a marriage match at age 16. There is no one Muslim culture. When Amal is challenged, as she sometimes is, to defend or explain Muslim terrorist actions, she says, "You're Christian, right?...what about the Ku klux Klan? ...They were really religious so obviously what they did was textbook Christianity, right?" This book makes clear that there are as many cultures mixed in with Islam as there are cultural mixes of Christianity, Judaism, or Buddhism.

There is not a clear plot to DOES MY HEAD LOOK BIG IN THIS?, it is instead a coming of age story, and the reader follows the various ups and downs of her friendships and family life through a haze of toe-nail polish and friend's diets and Cosmo quizzes and text-flirting. Although this is an accurate reflection of teen life, and so will appeal to that audience, those older may have a bit of a harder time sinking into the story. It was not long, though, before I was immersed in Amal's world. As her relationships with friends and family and neighbors flourish or suffer, the reader begins to empathize, feeling both Amal's courage and entrapment by her decision to wear her head scarf full time.

DOES MY HEAD LOOK BIG IN THIS? portrays people of Palestinian descent realistically. Skin tones range from white to dark and hair, though generally dark brown, ranges from curly to straight. Much attention is paid to clothing, particularly the head scarf, and time is taken to describe the different parts of the scarf, necessary anchoring around the head, and various possible color combinations. Although Amal does not know Arabic, only English, her conversations with those of similar culture are sprinkled by traditional Muslim greetings and expressions as well as Arabic names for foods and household items. As Dr. Vardell says, "it can be challenging to locate children's books which accurately reflect the experience of immigrants from the Middle East"2. DOES MY HEAD LOOK BIG IN THIS? is one of those rare books that accuratelyand authentically reflects this experience.

D. REVIEW EXCERPTS
Children's Literature:

Amal Mohamed Nasrullah Abdel-Hakim, a vivacious and witty teenager, has recently moved with her parents to Melbourne, Australia. The sixteen-year-old Australian-Muslim-Palestinian embraces her heritage and background, while her parents, Mohamed and Jamila, have a deep relationship with their daughter, always keeping Amal grounded with what is important in life. The Abdel-Hakim family resides in the suburbs of Melbourne, where Amal is adjusting to the move while she makes new and exciting friends. When her family moved, she had to leave all of her dear friends behind to attend McCleans Preparatory School full-time. Her friends are in for a big surprise when she shows up at school after their winter break wearing a hijab, a head scarf that symbolizes her religion and faith. Amal makes the life-changing decision to wear a hijab after watching an episode of Friends in which the character Rachel decides to wear a dreadful bridesmaid dress to her ex-boyfriend's wedding. The episode makes Amal passionate about wearing the scarf. Her parents, along with her principal, feel that wearing the scarf will only cause problems for Amal, but she decides that she is proud of her heritage and wants to embrace her culture, despite the consequences. In the beginning, she worries about the stereotypes she will face. Yazmeen, Amal's best friend, helps her deal with the pressure of wearing her hijab. As all of these events take place, she begins to see the world in a new light, realizing why wearing the hijab was so important in the beginning. One thing readers will gain from this book is knowledge of self-love and an appreciation of their culture. The author did a great job of presenting a story of aculture that is constantly maligned for their daily customs—especially in contemporary American media. This engaging text is presented in an intimate format similar to a diary, making Amal's story shine through the text and giving readers a sense of her every emotion. A must-read! Reviewer: Lacrisa Darby

VOYA:

The sight of Jennifer Aniston in a bridesmaid's dress creates an urge to change the channel for most viewers, but for witty, academically talented Amal Abdel-Hakim, it inspires the confidence to wear the hijab full time. As a Pakistani Australian Muslim, she has been teased about her religion, but in her decision to wear the hijab, she also has the support of loyal friends and her loving parents. Armed with fashion sense as well as faith, Amal sets out to match her hijab to her school clothes and modify her weekend wardrobe to flatter her assets as well as to express her belief in modesty. Not everyone is so accepting of her hijab, however. Classmates at her private high school ask her what she knows about terrorism, and a cranky neighbor makes no effort to hide her prejudices. Throughout the book, Amal makes candid yet astute observations on what it means to be a Muslim, a modern woman, and a good friend and daughter. Although the book addresses many teen issues including identity, family, religious traditions, and body image, it rarely strays into the realm of didactic. There is plenty of gentle humor, and strong female relationships balance Amal's racist classmates and a friend's crushingly traditional Muslim parent. In addition to her friendships, Amal also tries to deal with a crush that she knows will never develop into a romance and the hypocritical behaviors of some of her cousins. This novel is an excellent addition to the multicultural and chick-lit genres, and it is recommended for most collections.

KLIATT:

We have been waiting for just such a book as this in YA literature! Abdel-Fattah is a Muslim, an Egyptian-Palestinian-Australian who lives in Sydney. Her narrator is Amal, a smart junior in prep school, whose parents are professionals and who is heading in that direction herself, especially after a highly successful debating contest. Amal was a student at a Catholic school as a child, then at an Islamic school for several years, and now she is at a prep school where being Muslim is a distinct oddity. As the story begins, she is deciding that she wants to begin wearing a headscarf as a sign of her faith—hence the title. Even her parents are somewhat hesitant about this, since it will set Amal so thoroughly apart from the other students. Now, Amal is not someone who is especially pious—she loves junk TV, going out with friends to shop and gossip, and is generally a person any YA can like and relate to as they read about her—this is familiar chick lit with a new twist. What's so good about the story is just how easy it is for non-Muslim readers to relate to Amal; and I'm sure Muslim readers will snap this one up since they rarely see themselves portrayed in YA literature. A subplot concerns a friend of Amal's from the Islamic school: Leila is just as smart as Amal and yearns to continue her education and become a professional; however, her parents do not encourage her as Amal's parents encourage her. Instead, Leila's mother is trying to arrange her marriage and believes marriage and motherhood is all any good Muslim girl should want. Leila runs away to a women's shelter, and finally returns home with her mother's promise to let her continue her education. Here's a greatline as Amal reports how things are going: "Leila brought home the BBC production of Pride and Prejudice for an English assignment and her mother watched it with her. Apparently she was very impressed with Mrs. Bennet's matchmaking skills." Fun and just what we need in the way of diversity.


E. CONNECTIONS
BOOKS:
  • 10 Things I Hate About Me (by Randa Abdel-Fattah)
  • It's All About Us (by Shelley Adina)

ACTIVITIES:
___
1. Curt Dudley-Marling, "I'm Not from Pakistan' Multicultural Literature and the Problem of Representation", in Stories Matter: The Complexity of Cultural Authenticity in Children's Literature, ed. Dana L. Fox & Kathy G. Short (Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers) 311.
2.Vardell, Sylvia. "Culture 6 Inclusive Lit: Overview, http://online.twu.edu/webapps/portal/frameset.jsp?tab_id=_2_1&url=/webapps/blackboard/execute/launcher?type=Course&id=_37725_1&url=. (accessed August 5, 2009).