Wednesday, August 5, 2009

Rules




A. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Lord, Cynthia.2006. RULES. Scholastic Press: New York. ISBN 9780439443821.

B. PLOT SUMMARY

RULES is written from the perspective of twelve-year old Catherine, older sister to autistic David. Her family has just moved into a new neighborhood, and Catherine is scared that David will scare away new friends. Although she does make one almost friend in the neighborhood, it is complicated by the social politics of school. She receives an offer of friendship from the most unexpected source- a teenage boy in a wheelchair who cannot speak. He genuinely appreciates her art that she carries around in a notebook, and soon she is making word cards to help him communicate all the teenage emotions that his parents don't want to hear. Under all of this is Catherine's on-going relationship with her brother, which is a mixture of embarrassment, frustration, and genuinely trying to help him cope by creating "rules" he can memorize to make his life easier.

C. CRITICAL REVIEW

Dr. Vardell
quotes Hutchins and Heim in identifying five criteria by which to evaluate children's books that depict characters with disabilities: accuracy; avoidance of stereotypes; literary quality; confrontation of the disability and not "using" disabled characters.1 RULES does very well when evaluated by these criteria. RULES is accurate, most likely because the author Cynthia Lord wrote the book to "explore some of my own questions about living with someone who sees the world so differently than I do, but also to show a full experience of a family life with a child with autism: the happy moments, the heartbreaking ones, the ones that make me laugh." RULES avoids stereotypes, rather than using a disabled person to evoke fear (horror films featuring a serial killer in a wheelchair) or sympathy (Beth, in Little Women, always so weak and pale). David is a mischievous, innocent, force of nature. He is full of his own unique Davidness. RULES is well written, with short sentences that stick to the facts and lots of dialogue. RULES confronts autism straight on, it is never delegated to a background role, quite simply because lives associated with autistic individuals often must revolve around those people. Having worked for two years with autistic people, this aspect of autism speaks clearly to me. Finally, RULES does not use the disabled character. Although it is certainly true that Catherine learns about herself, continually, through her relationship with David.
There have been many books over the last few years featuring characters on the autistic-Asperger's spectrum. Most of them are highly functional and solve crimes, or have special abilities like Dustin Hoffman in Rainman. It is good that RULES is more realistic. One wonders where the books are on all the other disabilities. Where are the detectives in wheelchairs and with MS? One hopes they are coming soon.

D. REVIEW EXCERPTS

Publishers Weekly:

The appealing, credible narrator at the heart of Lord's debut novel will draw in readers, as she struggles to find order and balance in her life. Her parents place 12-year-old Catherine in charge of her younger autistic brother more often than she would like. Taking solace in art, the girl fills the back of her sketchbook with rules she has established for David, "so if my someday-he'll-wake-up-a-regular-brother wish doesn't ever come true, at least he'll know how the world works, and I won't have to keep explaining things." Sorely missing her best friend, who is away for the summer, and realizing that the girl who has just moved in next door is not a kindred spirit, Catherine devises some of her own self-protective rules ("When you want to get out of answering something, distract the questioner with another question"). In the able hands of the author, mother of an autistic child, Catherine's emotions come across as entirely convincing, especially her alternating devotion to and resentment of David, and her guilt at her impatience with him. Through her artwork, the heroine gradually opens up to Jason, a wheelchair-bound peer who can communicate only by pointing to words on cards. As she creates new cards that expand Jason's ability to express his feelings, their growing friendship enables Catherine to do the same. A rewarding story that may well inspire readers to think about others' points of view. Ages 9-12. (Apr.) Copyright 2006 Reed Business Information.

Joan Kindig, Ph.D. - Children's Literature:

Growing up with an autistic younger brother is not easy and it seems far harder when the pre-teen years hit. Catherine feels as though David's needs far overshadow her own in the family but the embarrassment his behavior causes her is the worst of it. Nevertheless, Catherine understands what David's world is like and when she snaps at him, she is beset by guilt. It is this sensitivity that allows her to befriend a boy her age with severe communication problems who is wheelchair-bound. Gaining a stronger sense of herself and demanding what she needs as a member of the family allows her to move beyond embarrassment into acceptance. This is a story that depicts the impact of a needy child on an entire family very realistically. One of the treats in this book is that David echoes words rather than generating his own and he frequently speaks in lines he remembers from Arnold Lobel's Frog & Toad. 2006, Scholastic, Ages 9 to 12.



E. CONNECTIONS
BOOKS:
  • The Curious Incident of the Dog in the Night-time (by Mark Haddon)
  • The London Eye Mystery (by Siobhan Dowd)
ACTIVITIES:
  • Nothing can replace interacting with Autistic people! Invite an autistic person to come and speak about his or her experience.


No comments: